Ira Sachs, the acclaimed New York-based filmmaker known for his sharply observed independent films like “Love Is Strange” and “Little Men,” never anticipated that his latest project ‘ Passages’ would receive an NC-17 rating. Sachs’ ninth feature, titled “Passages,” was conceived as a film of intimacy. Aiming to capture the closeness and tenderness missing from both real life and American movies during the pandemic.
Sachs, 57, expressed his desire to create a film that celebrated pleasure in all its forms. From sensuality and sexuality to the joy of cinema itself, encompassing colour, light, texture, and the human body. The film follows the story of Tomas, played by the talented young German actor Franz Rogowski. A Paris-based filmmaker who impulsively embarks on a passionate romance with Agatha, portrayed by Adèle Exarchopoulos, a French schoolteacher. This impulsive affair disrupts Tomas’ relationship with his husband, Martin, played by Ben Whishaw.
While “Passages” tastefully portrays the intricacies of human relationships, including the exploration of attraction, love, sex, dependence, and exasperation. Its honest and fleshy portrayal led the Motion Picture Association to assign the film its highest rating – NC-17. This rating prohibits admission for anyone under 17, regardless of whether they are accompanied by a parent or guardian.
Sachs Calls NC-17 Rating Homophobic and Outdated
Sachs strongly criticized the decision, deeming it homophobic, outdated, and out of touch with the essence of his film. He argues that nothing graphic is shown in “Passages,” making the NC-17 rating unjustified. Sachs also expressed concern about the impact of such a rating on other filmmakers. Suggesting that it may stifle creative expression by setting limits on what can be depicted on screen without facing repercussions.
The film’s intimate and emotionally charged scenes, particularly one between Tomas and Martin, have been a point of contention, leading to the contentious rating. However, Sachs remains adamant that explicitness is necessary to convey the authenticity and realism of the characters’ experiences.
Despite the controversy surrounding the rating, “Passages” will be released in theatres in New York and Los Angeles, and will later expand to other locations. Sachs hopes that audiences will appreciate the film’s exploration of human connections and its celebration of pleasure in all its complexities, beyond the limitations imposed by the NC-17 rating.